Genre Fantasy Publisher Roc Year Published 2000 Review Posted on 1/2/2008 Reviewer Rating
A Dance For Emilia, by Peter S Beagle
Book Review by Amy Harlib
Have you read this book?
American fantasy writer Peter S. Beagle has only published 6 books in the
last 30 some odd years, yet each was a gem, and two: "The Last Unicorn" and
"A Fine and Private Place" are considered bona fide classics of fantastic
fiction. His most recent (after Tamsin, 1999), returns to the 'gentle'
ghost story form of "A Fine and Private Place" and is a sweet and poignant
examination of dreams and the afterlife set in contemporary Manhattan.
The story is narrated by Jake Holtz, a 'working stiff' actor (nobody famous)
who is confronted with the profound when the spirit of his best friend who
died suddenly and unexpectedly of heart failure---failed dancer turned art
critic Sam Kagan---possesses the body of his female Abyssinian cat Millamont
two years after Sam's death. When the cat suddenly starts performing leaps,
twirls and acrobatic antics once impossible for his less supple human body
and starts 'speaking' in a sort of telepathic voice, Jake and Sam's most
recent lover Emilia Rossi (a local NJ newspaper reporter) with whom Jake has
formed a platonic friendship, are convinced that the power of their combined
grief and love has proved strong enough to bring Sam back to them in
Millamont's body. Yet, despite the human presence in the cat body,
Sam/Millamont retains very amusing feline behaviors!
Jake's narrative voice smoothly transitions from past to present as
flashbacks recall Jake's friendship with Sam, the two of them sharing a
passion for the performing arts and an understanding of the struggle to make
dreams come true. With concision and lyrical grace, Jake's prose conveys a
welter of convincing detail about the minutiae of adult life and feelings as
the two friends pursued demanding careers on opposite coasts---Sam writing
for arts magazines and Jake taking acting jobs wherever he can, mostly in
California, sometimes in NY and elsewhere---yet their relationship stayed
closer than ever. When Sam's unexpected death leaves Jake and Emilia
devastated, their shared mourning and love for Sam forges the bond of a new
friendship, and since Emilia inherited Millamont, Sam's cat---the miracle of
Sam returning to 'haunt' the feline's body somehow seems inevitable. But
some miracles do not last forever, or do they?
A Dance for Emilia, really a novella in a small format hardcover, manages
to pack into 87 pages, a full length novel's worth of character-driven,
vividly detailed story rich in heartfelt musings on love, longing and the
power of bonds between people, all painlessly conveyed through Jake's
sobering reflections and witty dialogue. The book's combination of intense
emotions, colorful descriptions of people and places, permeated throughout
with an oddly poignant yet beautiful mood, makes the inclusion of the eerie
and the uncanny convincing, especially at the tale's bittersweet yet
satisfying conclusion. This charmingly unconventional example of the ghost
story subgenre of fantasy is perfect as a gift to oneself and especially to
a special friend, for Beagle offers not only an entertaining, brief,
supernaturally-tinged yarn, but also something more: "Not facts, but the
accuracy under and around and beyond facts. Not a recital of events---not
even honesty---but truth". A Dance for Emilia is a book for everyone!