SELECT * FROM uv_BookReviewRollup WHERE recordnum = 1385 The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz Book Review | SFReader.com

The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz cover image

The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz
Genre: Fantasy
Publisher: Rogue Blades Entertainment
Published: 2008
Review Posted: 10/15/2009
Reviewer Rating:
Reader Rating: 9 out of 10

The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz

Book Review by Gustavo Bondoni

Have you read this book?

A collection of tales of adventure and the struggle against insurmountable odds with well-developed characters and important issues at stake. This one definitely isn't a collection of gaming sessions placed back to back.

Whenever I receive a publication that holds large quantities of Sword and Sorcery, my first concern is that the contributors are a bunch of amateurs who think their D&D sessions would make interesting reading, and never manage to understand why they don't. I needn't have worried. A quick glance at the table of contents was enough to convince me that this one was something special -- it isn't every day that I pick up a book and find that almost every author is not only someone I've heard of, but someone whose work I've read and enjoyed elsewhere.

So the bar was set high, and the stories didn't disappoint, showing core S&S as it was meant to be -- not just muscle-bound barbarians hacking magicians to bits, but muscle-bound barbarians hacking magicians to bits for valid reasons and with real emotion behind it. The stories strike a balance between entertainment and character development that is satisfying from both a literary and an adventure point of view.

The selection is well balanced, spanning the range from wyrd-doomed warriors to persecuted pirates and from old has-beens to young magicians trying to claim their birthright. Each story takes us to a different world, with different rules and customs. But the world-building doesn't get in the way of the action. None of these stories are about pages and pages of lush description, they are about action, and we get plenty of it. Monsters, magicians, vampires, mazes, elementals, and other things with no name, are all dealt with in various ways, and fans of S&S will be left well-satisfied with the heft of the book and the contents.

But this book can also be enjoyed by novices. If you're curious to see what S&S is all about, this is one heck of a place to start -- and to meet writers whose work you will then obsessively hunt down all over the place.

A couple of stories stood out for me -- "What Heroes Leave Behind" by Nicholas Ian Hawkins is a somewhat poignant story of an aging warrior who, nevertheless, accepts his duty and "The Red Worm's Way" by James Enge, a convoluted tale in which nothing, and no one is what they seem.

Being an antho, of course, there are some stories I enjoyed less than others, which has more to do with my own tastes than with the quality of the writing. Also, I didn't particularly agree with the editor's choice, and there was a long article on writing which I felt was out of place -- the article itself was outstanding, but it did break the rhythm that the stories themselves created.

Nevertheless, this is a book that I can recommend with no qualms whatsoever -- it is extremely effective in doing what it sets out to do, and can be enjoyed by everyone from teens with a lust for adventure to college professors who appreciate good writing.

Click here to buy The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz on Amazon

The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz on Amazon

The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz cover pic
Comment on The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz
Your Name:
Comment:
Type (case sensitive) here:

Comments on The Return of the Sword, edited by Jason M. Waltz
There are no comments on this book.